The Commander format, also known as Elder Dragon Highlander (EDH), is a popular variant of Magic: The Gathering that uses a 100-card singleton deck with a legendary creature as the commander. The EDH ban list is a list of cards that are not allowed in EDH decks, and it is updated once a year by the Rules Committee.
The 2024 EDH ban list was announced on January 1, 2024, and it includes a number of new cards that are now banned, as well as some cards that were previously banned but have been unbanned. Here’s a look at some of the most notable changes to the EDH banned list for 2024:
With the 2024 EDH ban list now in effect, players will need to adjust their decks accordingly. Some decks that were previously legal may now be illegal, and some cards that were previously banned may now be allowed. It’s important to check the EDH ban list before you build or play a deck to make sure that it complies with the rules.
Edh Banned List 2024
Significant changes to Commander format.
- New cards banned: Hullbreacher, Lurrus of the Dream-Den.
- Cards unbanned: Paradox Engine, Flash.
- Rule changes: Partial Paris mulligan allowed.
- Updated banlist philosophy: Focus on preserving color identity.
- Commander Legends sets: Considered for banlist decisions.
- Community feedback: Considered in banlist updates.
- Annual review: Banlist reviewed and updated yearly.
- Player impact: Banned cards may impact deck construction.
The EDH ban list is subject to change in the future, so players should stay up-to-date on the latest changes.
New cards banned: Hullbreacher, Lurrus of the Dream-Den.
Two cards that have been banned in the 2024 EDH ban list are Hullbreacher and Lurrus of the Dream-Den. These cards have been deemed to be too powerful and disruptive for the Commander format.
Hullbreacher is a blue creature that allows its controller to draw cards whenever an opponent casts a spell. This can quickly lead to card advantage and can be very difficult for opponents to deal with. Lurrus of the Dream-Den is a black creature that allows its controller to cast spells from their graveyard for free. This can be a very powerful ability, especially in decks that are built around reanimating creatures.
The Rules Committee has stated that these cards were banned because they are “too oppressive and warping in the Commander format.” They also stated that these cards “promote unhealthy play patterns and make it difficult for players to interact with each other.”
The banning of these cards is likely to have a significant impact on the Commander format. Decks that rely on these cards will need to be adjusted, and new decks will need to be built without them.
Overall, the banning of Hullbreacher and Lurrus of the Dream-Den is a significant change to the Commander format. It is likely to have a major impact on the way the format is played, and it will be interesting to see how the community adapts to these changes.
Cards unbanned: Paradox Engine, Flash.
Two cards that have been unbanned in the 2024 EDH ban list are Paradox Engine and Flash. These cards were previously banned because they were deemed to be too powerful and disruptive for the Commander format. However, the Rules Committee has decided to unban these cards because they believe that they can now be played in a healthy and balanced way.
Paradox Engine is a colorless artifact that allows its controller to untap all of their permanents whenever they cast a spell. This can lead to some very powerful combos, especially in decks that are built around casting multiple spells in a single turn. Flash is a blue instant that allows its controller to cast a creature spell at instant speed. This can be a very powerful ability, especially in decks that are built around tempo and disruption.
The Rules Committee has stated that these cards were unbanned because they “have been power-creeped by other cards and strategies in the format.” They also stated that they believe that these cards “can now be played in a fair and balanced way.”
The unbanning of these cards is likely to have a significant impact on the Commander format. Decks that were previously unable to play these cards will now be able to do so, and new decks will be built around these cards.
Overall, the unbanning of Paradox Engine and Flash is a significant change to the Commander format. It is likely to have a major impact on the way the format is played, and it will be interesting to see how the community adapts to these changes.
Rule changes: Partial Paris mulligan allowed.
One of the most significant changes to the Commander format in the 2024 ban list update is the allowance of the Partial Paris mulligan. This is a new mulligan option that allows players to keep a hand of any size, but they must exile cards from their hand equal to the number of cards they kept. For example, if a player keeps a hand of 6 cards, they must exile 1 card from their hand.
The Partial Paris mulligan is designed to address two problems with the previous mulligan rule. First, it can be very difficult to get a good hand in Commander, especially with the high deck size and singleton nature of the format. Second, the previous mulligan rule could lead to players taking mulligans until they had a perfect hand, which could slow down the game and make it less fun for everyone involved.
The Partial Paris mulligan is a compromise between these two extremes. It allows players to keep a hand of any size, but they are still penalized for taking mulligans. This should help to speed up the game and make it more fun for everyone involved.
The Partial Paris mulligan is still in its early stages, and it is possible that it could be tweaked or even removed in the future. However, for now, it is a welcome addition to the Commander format.
Overall, the allowance of the Partial Paris mulligan is a significant change to the Commander format. It is likely to have a major impact on the way the format is played, and it will be interesting to see how the community adapts to this change.
Updated banlist philosophy: Focus on preserving color identity.
One of the most significant changes to the EDH ban list philosophy in 2024 is the focus on preserving color identity. This means that the Rules Committee is now more likely to ban cards that break the color pie or that allow players to play cards outside of their commander’s color identity.
-
Banning cards that break the color pie.
The color pie is a fundamental part of Magic: The Gathering, and it helps to define the strengths and weaknesses of each color. Banning cards that break the color pie helps to preserve the integrity of the game and ensures that all colors have a fair chance to compete.
-
Banning cards that allow players to play cards outside of their commander’s color identity.
The color identity of a Commander deck is determined by the colors of the commander and any cards that produce mana of those colors. Banning cards that allow players to play cards outside of their commander’s color identity helps to ensure that decks are consistent and that players are not able to cheat by playing cards that they should not be able to.
-
Promoting a diverse and healthy metagame.
The Rules Committee wants to promote a diverse and healthy metagame in Commander. This means that they are more likely to ban cards that are too powerful or that warp the format in a negative way. By banning these cards, the Rules Committee hopes to ensure that all decks have a fair chance to compete and that the format remains fun and enjoyable for everyone.
-
Listening to player feedback.
The Rules Committee is always listening to player feedback when it comes to the banlist. They want to hear from players about which cards they think are too powerful or unfair. The Rules Committee also wants to hear from players about which cards they think should be unbanned. By listening to player feedback, the Rules Committee can make informed decisions about which cards to ban and unban.
The focus on preserving color identity is a significant change to the EDH ban list philosophy. It is likely to have a major impact on the way the format is played, and it will be interesting to see how the community adapts to this change.
Commander Legends sets: Considered for banlist decisions.
Another significant change to the EDH ban list process in 2024 is the consideration of Commander Legends sets. Previously, cards from Commander Legends sets were not eligible for banlist consideration until the following year. However, the Rules Committee has decided to change this policy in order to address the increasing power level of cards in these sets.
-
Cards from Commander Legends sets are now eligible for banlist consideration immediately.
This means that the Rules Committee can now ban cards from Commander Legends sets if they believe that they are too powerful or disruptive for the Commander format.
-
The Rules Committee will be monitoring the impact of Commander Legends sets on the format.
The Rules Committee wants to ensure that Commander Legends sets do not have a negative impact on the format. They will be monitoring the impact of these sets and will take action if necessary.
-
The Rules Committee is committed to keeping the Commander format healthy and balanced.
The Rules Committee wants to ensure that the Commander format remains fun and enjoyable for everyone. They will continue to monitor the format and will make changes to the banlist as necessary.
-
Player feedback is important.
The Rules Committee wants to hear from players about their experiences with Commander Legends sets. Players can provide feedback to the Rules Committee by emailing them at banned@mtgcommander.net.
The consideration of Commander Legends sets for banlist decisions is a significant change to the EDH ban list process. It is likely to have a major impact on the way the format is played, and it will be interesting to see how the community adapts to this change.
Community feedback: Considered in banlist updates.
The Rules Committee values community feedback when making decisions about the EDH ban list. They want to hear from players about their experiences with the format and which cards they think are too powerful or unfair. Players can provide feedback to the Rules Committee by emailing them at banned@mtgcommander.net.
The Rules Committee considers all feedback that they receive, but they do not always agree with everyone. They have to weigh the feedback that they receive against their own knowledge of the format and their vision for the future of the format.
However, the Rules Committee has made it clear that they do listen to community feedback and that it does influence their decisions. For example, in the 2024 ban list update, the Rules Committee banned the card Hullbreacher based in part on feedback from the community. Players had been complaining that Hullbreacher was too powerful and disruptive, and the Rules Committee agreed.
The Rules Committee is committed to keeping the Commander format healthy and balanced. They believe that community feedback is an important part of this process. By listening to the community, the Rules Committee can make informed decisions about which cards to ban and unban.
Overall, the Rules Committee’s consideration of community feedback is a positive development for the EDH format. It shows that the Rules Committee is listening to the community and that they are willing to make changes to the ban list based on feedback.
Annual review: Banlist reviewed and updated yearly.
The EDH ban list is reviewed and updated once a year by the Rules Committee. This ensures that the ban list is always up-to-date with the latest cards and trends in the format. The Rules Committee also uses this time to review any feedback that they have received from the community and to make any necessary changes to the ban list philosophy.
The annual review process is an important part of keeping the Commander format healthy and balanced. It allows the Rules Committee to make changes to the ban list based on the latest data and feedback. This helps to ensure that the format remains fun and enjoyable for everyone.
The annual review process also helps to keep the Commander format from becoming stale. By banning and unbanning cards on a regular basis, the Rules Committee can help to keep the format fresh and exciting. This encourages players to try new strategies and decks, which helps to keep the format diverse and interesting.
Overall, the annual review of the EDH ban list is a positive development for the format. It helps to keep the format healthy, balanced, and fresh. It also shows that the Rules Committee is committed to listening to the community and making changes to the ban list as needed.
The next annual review of the EDH ban list will take place in January 2025. Players can expect to see some changes to the ban list at that time, based on the latest data and feedback.
Player impact: Banned cards may impact deck construction.
One of the most significant impacts of the EDH ban list is on deck construction. When a card is banned, players can no longer use it in their decks. This can have a major impact on the viability of certain decks and strategies.
For example, the banning of Hullbreacher in the 2024 ban list update will have a significant impact on decks that rely on wheel effects. Wheel effects are cards that allow players to draw a number of cards and then discard the same number of cards. Hullbreacher was a powerful wheel effect because it allowed players to draw cards while also denying their opponents cards. With Hullbreacher banned, players will need to find other ways to draw cards and disrupt their opponents.
The banning of cards can also lead to the creation of new decks and strategies. When a powerful card is banned, players are forced to find new ways to win. This can lead to the development of new and innovative decks that were not possible before.
Overall, the impact of the EDH ban list on deck construction is significant. Banned cards can have a major impact on the viability of certain decks and strategies. However, the banning of cards can also lead to the creation of new decks and strategies. This helps to keep the format fresh and exciting.
Players who are affected by the EDH ban list should take some time to review their decks and make any necessary changes. They may need to find new cards to replace the banned cards, or they may need to adjust their deck strategy altogether. However, with a little creativity, players can still build powerful and competitive decks that comply with the ban list.
FAQ
Here are some frequently asked questions about the 2024 EDH ban list:
Question 1: What cards were banned in the 2024 ban list update?
Answer 1: Hullbreacher and Lurrus of the Dream-Den were banned in the 2024 ban list update.
Question 2: What cards were unbanned in the 2024 ban list update?
Answer 2: Paradox Engine and Flash were unbanned in the 2024 ban list update.
Question 3: Why were Hullbreacher and Lurrus of the Dream-Den banned?
Answer 3: Hullbreacher and Lurrus of the Dream-Den were banned because they were deemed to be too powerful and disruptive for the Commander format.
Question 4: Why were Paradox Engine and Flash unbanned?
Answer 4: Paradox Engine and Flash were unbanned because the Rules Committee believes that they can now be played in a fair and balanced way.
Question 5: What is the Partial Paris mulligan?
Answer 5: The Partial Paris mulligan is a new mulligan option that allows players to keep a hand of any size, but they must exile cards from their hand equal to the number of cards they kept.
Question 6: Why was the Partial Paris mulligan added to the Commander format?
Answer 6: The Partial Paris mulligan was added to the Commander format to address the problem of getting a good hand in Commander, especially with the high deck size and singleton nature of the format.
Question 7: How does the ban list impact deck construction?
Answer 7: Banned cards can have a major impact on deck construction. When a card is banned, players can no longer use it in their decks. This can force players to find new cards to replace the banned cards or to adjust their deck strategy altogether.
Question 8: How can I stay up-to-date on the latest changes to the EDH ban list?
Answer 8: You can stay up-to-date on the latest changes to the EDH ban list by visiting the official Commander website or by following the Rules Committee on social media.
Closing Paragraph for FAQ:
These are just a few of the most frequently asked questions about the 2024 EDH ban list. If you have any other questions, you can email the Rules Committee at banned@mtgcommander.net.
Now that you know all about the 2024 EDH ban list, you can start building your new decks! Check out our tips section for some helpful advice on how to build a powerful and competitive EDH deck.
Tips
Here are some tips for building a powerful and competitive EDH deck in 2024:
Tip 1: Consider the new ban list.
The 2024 EDH ban list has some significant changes, so it’s important to review the list and make sure that your deck is compliant. You may need to find new cards to replace the banned cards, or you may need to adjust your deck strategy altogether.
Tip 2: Build around a strong commander.
The commander is the most important card in your EDH deck. Choose a commander that you like to play and that has a powerful ability. Your commander should be the centerpiece of your deck and should help you to win games.
Tip 3: Choose your cards carefully.
Every card in your EDH deck should have a purpose. Don’t just add cards to your deck because you think they’re cool or because they’re powerful. Every card should contribute to your deck’s overall strategy.
Tip 4: Don’t forget about your mana base.
The mana base is the foundation of your EDH deck. Make sure that you have enough lands to cast your spells and that you have a good mix of basic lands and non-basic lands.
Tip 5: Test your deck and make adjustments.
Once you’ve built your EDH deck, it’s important to test it out and make adjustments. Playtest your deck against other decks to see how it performs. Make changes to your deck as needed to improve its performance.
Closing Paragraph for Tips:
By following these tips, you can build a powerful and competitive EDH deck that will help you to win games and have fun.
Now that you have some tips for building an EDH deck, it’s time to put your knowledge into practice. Gather your cards and start brewing! With a little creativity and effort, you can build a deck that will be the envy of your friends.
Conclusion
The 2024 EDH ban list update is a significant change to the Commander format. The banning of Hullbreacher and Lurrus of the Dream-Den and the unbanning of Paradox Engine and Flash are likely to have a major impact on the way the format is played.
The new Partial Paris mulligan is also a welcome addition to the Commander format. It should help to address the problem of getting a good hand in Commander, especially with the high deck size and singleton nature of the format.
Overall, the 2024 EDH ban list update is a positive development for the Commander format. It shows that the Rules Committee is listening to the community and is committed to keeping the format healthy and balanced.
Closing Message:
With the 2024 EDH ban list now in effect, it’s time to start thinking about how you’re going to adjust your decks. There are a lot of new possibilities to explore, so be creative and have fun! The Commander format is more diverse and exciting than ever before.